Piling on the pressure

Download the report

Report in Portuguese

Summary:

Portugal’s pulp and paper sector is making record profits despite the current intersecting global crises. Its heavy investments in biomass electricity are a contributing factor, and it now produces almost 80% of the electricity generated from burning biomass in Portugal through its combined heat and power  (CHP) and electricity-only power stations, and operates over half of the dedicated biomass electricity capacity.

Underlying the sector’s focus on biomass electricity are generous renewable energy subsidies. This incentive for burning woody biomass has encouraged the pulp and paper sector to decouple biomass burning from relying on by-products of the pulping process as a feedstock. Less than half of the woody biomass burned by the sector comes from bark and other industrial by-products, with the majority being sourced directly from forestry operations.

The two most significant recent developments are Altri/GreenVolt’s 34.5MW electricity-only biomass power station in Figueira da Foz, and The Navigator Company’s neighbouring biomass boiler that replaced a fossil gas combined heat and power (CHP) plant. Both are dependent on large volumes of woody biomass directly from forestry operations, and have been financed as “green” developments.

In total, six electricity-only biomass power stations and five CHP plants associated with the pulp and paper industry burn around 2.9 million tonnes of woody biomass each year, more than any  other sector. Over half of this comes directly from forestry operations. Pulp and paper companies  claim that only forestry residues and industrial by-products are burned in their power stations, but far more woody biomass is burned by the biomass energy and wood pellet industries each year than could be available as genuine residues, as defined in Portuguese legislation.

The pulp sector claims that burning woody biomass helps it to meet its climate targets and reduce the risk of wildfires. However, biomass electricity often results in greater emissions than fossil fuel equivalents, and in recent years the scale of wildfires has only increased, particularly in forestry areas, as biomass electricity capacity has grown. On top of this, the over-extraction of woody  biomass from forestry areas is harming soil health and adding to pressure for the expansion of harmful eucalyptus plantations.

Three key areas of action that must be taken are:

• The introduction of an immediate moratorium on new biomass electricity capacity, and ending its eligibility for renewable energy subsidies;
• A cap on woody biomass consumption at pulp mills so that only secondary biomass (i.e. pulp mill and other wood processing by-products) are used as feedstock for energy generation;
• For subsidies for biomass electricity generation to be redirected towards genuinely  renewable energy generation, energy efficiency and fire risk reduction techniques that incentivise the conservation and regeneration of native forests.